My family would like to welcome you back to our Would You Rather Challenge: October 6, 2025. The challenge allows us to ask each other a question from the children’s book The Ultimate Book of Would You Rather Questions: 1001 Family-Friendly Challenges for Kids, Teens and Adults written by Author by Kimberly McLeod (Author).
We’ve used this children’s book when #Homeschooling Charlie in his reading class to get conversation flowing and our family off of electronics. I also share the question on Facebook for my friends and family to answer.
Would you rather have freshly baked Cookies or a freshly baked Pie? Why?
Charlie isn’t a sweet person most of the time but does like Cake Mix not cooked and un-Cooked Cookies at times but no, Pie’s at all. Charlie said he would choose Fresh Baked Cookies if he can choose which Cookies to have.
David said bring on the Pie and it can be any flavor of Pie although he does like Cookies as well. For me since I only like Apple Pie or No Bake Chocolate Pie with Whipped Cream Topping but all kinds of Cookies, I would choose Cookies so I can share with Charlie. Bring on the Milk please.
Would you rather have freshly baked Cookies or a freshly baked Pie? Why?
Thank you,
Glenda, Charlie and David Cates
